Karl Bimshas Consulting

MANAGE BETTER LEAD WELL

  • Welcome
    • About Us
    • Karl Bimshas
      • Leadership Point of View
      • Bio
    • FAQs
    • Why Value-Based Fixed Fees
    • Statement of Privacy
  • Leadership Development
    • Do I Need an Accountability Partner?
      • Kick-Ass Boss
    • Leadership Scorecard
    • Leadership Assessments
      • Core Competencies Index
      • DISC
      • DISC Lite
  • Optimize Your Leadership
  • Books
    • Bimshas Books
      • How to Stay When You Want to Quit
      • Welcome to Leadership
      • Give A Damn
      • Disposable Journal
      • Pushing Back the Ocean
      • 132 Leadership Tips
    • Leadership Workbooks
      • Perspectives
      • Lead on Purpose
      • Sales Management Monthly Briefing
      • Mind Map Workbook
    • The Manage Better Lead Well Series
  • Testimonials
    • Interviews
  • Contact
    • Friends Don’t Let Friends Become Lousy Leaders
    • Payment Page
  • Sign up!
    • Newsletter
    • Update Your Information
    • Links
      • More Links
        • Your 90-Day Review
        • Monthly Offer
    • Surveys
      • Do My Employees Need Coaching?
    • Invitation
      • INFO AND INVITATION
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Podcast
      • Past Episodes
        • Leadership In Unusual Times
          • Podcast Questions
    • Lyderis
      • DISC Bonus
      • Leadership Library
        • Invitation to The Leadership Library
    • Mini-Courses
      • Explain That Behavior
      • Lead On Purpose Course
    • Ways to Praise
    • Leadership Development Box
    • Leadership Goal-Setting
    • The Solution Exchange
    • Compass
    • Be The Kind of Leader Who Gives a CRAP

Does Your Criticism Suck?

April 2, 2018 Karl Bimshas

Leadership takes many forms and comes from many voices. We want more of those leadership voices heard, so we occasionally publish a guest post on our “Reflections on Leadership” blog. This one is from 30-something millennial, Jenny Christopher. If you have a leadership point of view you want to share or have feedback you think other leaders need to hear so they can manage better and lead well, reach out to us. We would love to hear from you.

Making better humans takes more than, “A job well done!”
My 3rd-grade teacher was nice, and she would smile and always comment on what a good job I was doing. Now that I am in the middle of my career, I reflect back on past managers and realize that, although most of them used praise as feedback during my annual reviews, some managers failed to explain in words what was “so good” about how I did things. They most certainly did not provide the guidelines on how to improve. I crave the days of college when my ten-page paper was stained with scribbled red ink. Why aren’t supervisors doling out words of wisdom? Have they tried and were met with confrontation or is constructive criticism excluded from general managerial training?

If it “works” then why doesn’t it work for me (as a leader/manager)?
There is numerous research that highlights the power of using constructive feedback as a means for increasing group members’ confidence for attaining desired outcomes (Jung & Sosik, 2003, p. 372). Feedback is a powerful tool that some expect to hear at the office, similar to the phrase, “Happy Friday!” If you are the manager that has stumbled into a confrontation in the past, accept that people are human and humans see criticism as a primal threat. Sometimes, our brains go into protection mode and overanalyze the information they just received so once again they are in the right. Criticism is hard to take gracefully when you are battling biology (read below on taking criticism). Additionally, there is not a perfect model of feedback for everyone and feedback should be tailored to specific identities and motivations. As a supervisor, your ultimate goal should be to make better humans, not simply behavior modification. If you truly want to advance the (sometimes innate) skills of your staff and see them flourish, your feedback will be viewed as trustworthy and genuine by its receivers. Making sure feedback is timely, clear, and interactive is paramount to getting positive results.

You can dish it, but can you take it?
Think back to your 7 am yoga class when your instructor reminded you to evoke your intention during that downward dog pose. If you look behind the curtain of criticism, there is good old intention operating all the controls. Accepting criticism is easier if you assume good intent. It is your supervisor’s job to mold you into a better human being, and unless there are obvious ulterior motives, chances are they take your professional growth as a personal failure or achievement. We all hate to hear it, especially when we would rather succumb to laziness, but practice makes perfect. Ask for feedback instead of waiting for it to come to you. The more you get used to hearing it the better you will become at receiving it. Take initiative of your growth and come up with a list of questions that you can ask your supervisor after you finish a project or after attending a work event.

Jung, D. I., & Sosik, J. J. (2003). Group potency and collective efficacy: Examining their predictive validity, level and analysis, and effects of performance feedback on future group performance. Group & Organization Management, 28, 366-391. doi:10.1177/1059601102250821


Guest post written by Jenny Christopher, a 30-something millennial who hasn’t spent more than four years at one job. She has bounced from industries in, information technology, environmental consulting, eco/adventure-tourism, and environmental education. She has a B.A. from San Diego State University in business administration & marketing, with a minor in economics and an M.S. in in environmental education and interpretation from the University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point.

If you liked this, share it!
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Reddit
  • Whatsapp
  • Email
  • Print

Communication, Feedback, Leadership, Reflections on Leadership Career Management, Criticism, guest post, Jenny Christopher, Personal Development

Search Here

Visit Leadershirts Plus

Key Links

  • Do I Need an Accountability Partner?
  • Do My Employees Need Coaching?
  • Leadership Point of View
  • Kick-Ass Boss
  • Bimshas Books
  • Blog
  • DISC
  • Resources
  • Why Value-Based Fixed Fees
  • User’s Guide
Reflections on Leadership Podcast

RSS The Podcast

  • 372. The 4 Musts
  • 371. What’s Worse, Executive or AI Hallucinations?
  • 370. Do You WANT Leadership Development?
  • 369. Why Leadership? Why You?
  • 368. Building a Successful Team
  • 367. Leadership Beyond Popularity
  • 366. Leadership Principles

Latest Books on Amazon

Popular Products

  • Disposable Journal
  • Give A Damn
  • Perspectives
  • Leadership Scorecard

Recent Posts

  • Be a Reflective Leader
  • 247
  • Is This Leader Any Good?
  • Boosting Performance with Confidence and Support
  • Leadership That Burns Bright or Burns Out

© 2023 Karl Bimshas Consulting

Contact

Karl Bimshas Consulting
2150 Comstock Street #710192
San Diego, CA 92111
1-619-717-6204
info@KarlBimshasConsulting.com

Where to Start

  • 1. Browse the Resources Page
  • 2. Assess Your Leadership Attributes
  • 3. Do You Need an Accountability Partner?
  • 4. Act on Purpose – Leadership Goal-Setting

Copyright © 2023 · Equilibre on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in